London Governance & Compliance Academy

eShop ｜Training Calendar｜ On Demand ｜ Platform Login ｜ Contact

Handling Conflicts of Interest

Homepage > LGCA Blog > Handling Conflicts of Interest

A conflict of interest arises when an individual’s personal interests interfere, or have the potential to interfere, with their professional duties and responsibilities. In essence, it occurs when a personal gain could influence professional decision-making, potentially compromising the interests of other stakeholders.

Conflicts of interest can have serious consequences, both for individuals and organisations. In the short term, they can lead to unethical behaviour, mistrust and a decline in organisational performance. In the long term, such conflicts can tarnish reputations, lead to legal repercussions and ultimately result in a loss of stakeholder confidence. It’s therefore crucial that conflicts of interest are identified, managed and prevented wherever possible to maintain integrity within professional environments.

 

What does a conflict  of interest look like in practice?

 

A classic example of conflict of interest occurred in the 2008 financial crisis involving Goldman Sachs. The global investment bank had created complex financial products tied to the American mortgage market and sold these to their clients. Simultaneously, without notifying their clients, the bank bet against these products, thus benefiting from the impending financial crisis at the expense of their own clients

Another case involved Standard Chartered bank in 2014, where an executive director held multiple roles, thus having conflicting interests. The executive was not only a director of the bank but also a senior executive in its largest shareholder, Temasek. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) deemed this as a potential conflict of interest, since the executive’s decision-making could be influenced by his different roles.

 

UK and European Regulations

 

The FCA, the UK’s primary financial regulatory body, sets guidelines for managing conflicts of interest. Notably, the Senior Management Arrangements, Systems and Controls (SYSC) sourcebook includes rules requiring firms to establish, implement and maintain an effective conflicts of interest policy (SYSC 10).

Simultaneously, European directives provide a framework for managing conflicts of interest across EU member states. One such directive is the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II). MiFID II, which came into effect in January 2018. It imposes obligations on firms to take all appropriate steps to identify, prevent, manage and disclose conflicts of interest. It applies to a wide range of firms including banks, brokers, and investment firms. MiFID III will further strengthen these requirements when it is fully implemented. The FCA has confirmed the implementation timeline in the UK as being phased with a deadline of 31 July 2023 for all in scope new and existing products and services that are open to sale or renewal and 31 July 2024 for closed products and services.

In addition, the European Banking Authority (EBA) Guidelines on Internal Governance (2017) necessitate banks to have robust governance arrangements, including clear organisational structure with effective mechanisms to identify and manage conflicts of interest.

 

These regulations and guidelines collectively create a comprehensive framework to manage conflicts of interest in the financial industry, making clear the responsibility of firms to act ethically and in the best interests of their clients. It is paramount that firms understand and adhere to these regulations to uphold their integrity and maintain stakeholder confidence.

 

How Conflicts of Interest Relate to Governance and Compliance in Organisations

Properly addressing conflicts of interest is a fundamental part of effective governance and compliance. Governance, the systems and processes by which organisations are directed and controlled, clearly plays a vital role in managing conflicts of interest. Effective governance structures promote transparency, accountability and ethical decision-making. A central part of this involves establishing and enforcing guidelines for dealing with conflicts of interest to ensure organisational integrity and protect stakeholders’ interests.

Compliance, the process of ensuring adherence to both internal policies and external regulations, is another crucial element in addressing conflicts of interest. A strong compliance programme can help to prevent and detect conflicts of interest through policy implementation, continuous training and active monitoring.

However, for governance and compliance efforts to be successful, they must be underpinned by a strong organisational culture that prioritises ethical conduct and transparency. Top management should actively promote such a culture, setting the tone for acceptable behaviour and leading by example. It should also be noted that managing conflicts of interest is a shared responsibility between governance and compliance. Together, they form an effective system for identifying, managing, and mitigating conflicts of interest, thereby safeguarding organisational integrity and maintaining stakeholder trust.

 

Technology and the future

Conflicts of interest in financial firms can have significant negative repercussions, as illustrated by the real-world examples above. Regulations like SYSC 10 and MiFID II provide a framework to mitigate such instances. Robust governance and adherence to compliance are paramount in managing these conflicts, sustaining the integrity of the financial sector, and maintaining stakeholders’ trust.

Technological advancements, particularly in artificial intelligence (AI), are paving the way for innovative solutions in managing conflicts of interest in the financial industry. AI tools, with capabilities like data mining and pattern recognition, can identify potential conflicts of interest more swiftly and accurately than traditional methods. In addition to technology, regulatory bodies are considering new proposals to reduce such conflicts. These include increasing transparency requirements, strengthening penalties for non-compliance, and emphasising individual accountability.

Looking ahead, the combined impact of advanced technology and evolving regulations promises a more robust framework for managing conflicts of interest. The future will likely see financial organisations leveraging AI to proactively identify and mitigate these conflicts, bolstered by a stronger regulatory environment that further discourages unethical behaviour. All of this is in the service of preventing mistrust, maintaining organisational performance and bolstering stakeholder confidence.

References: